Rare 1858 Quarter Errors (List & Pictures)
The recognized FS-901 variety gives 1858 Liberty Seated quarter errors an unusual connection to the Flying Eagle cent. Estimated whole-coin values run from $1,000–$10,000.
A related 1857 example sold for $7,050 in February 2016, a different-year comparison rather than an 1858 auction record. Inspect the extra reverse shapes around the eagle and shield, then match them to the actual 1858 variety.
1858 Quarter Cent-Design Traces around the Eagle: Mismatched Die Clash Error
The FS-901 quarter reverse carries faint shapes linked to the reverse of a Flying Eagle cent. They appear around the quarter eagle’s wings and within its shield, alongside the normal quarter design.
The dies, or steel stamping tools, contacted each other without a blank separating them. That collision marked the quarter die, which subsequently transferred the extra traces onto silver quarters.
This is not a quarter with a complete cent face substituted for one side. Both normal quarter faces remain, with additional details inherited from the damaged tool.
PCGS records an 1858 example graded AU58, indicating only slight wear. That gives a date-specific variety comparison without supplying a sale price for the coin.
How to Identify
Begin with an ordinary quarter reverse to learn which feather edges and shield stripes belong in the design. Otherwise, a normal fine line can look like an unexpected transfer.
With magnification, examine the areas above the wings and inside the shield. The additional shapes must fit the cent’s reverse design in the correct positions.
Compare them with the identified 1858 FS-901, keeping nearby quarter features visible. Several matching traces carry more weight than one odd line beside a wing.
The related 1857 variety is useful context but cannot replace the correct-year reference. Die polishing and later wear can affect the strength of individual surviving marks.
Include the full 1858 date, both faces, and close-ups taken under changing light. Random scratches should not be combined into an imagined cent design simply because they cross the same general area.
What It’s Worth
$1,000–$10,000 is the estimated whole-coin range for correctly identified 1858 examples. Original surfaces and clearly surviving transferred shapes influence collector interest.
The supplied auction comparison is an 1857 FS-901 graded PCGS MS64 that brought $7,050 on February 5, 2016. It was unworn, unlike the recorded 1858 AU58.
Both the year and preservation differ. That sale demonstrates interest in this unusual clash mechanism without guaranteeing the price of another coin or every faint clash mark.
Conclusion
An 1858 FS-901 quarter preserves evidence of contact between different coin dies. Its extra reverse shapes come from the Flying Eagle cent’s design, while the coin still carries its ordinary quarter faces.
Match several traces to the 1858 reference before using the $1,000–$10,000 estimate. The $7,050 result belongs to an unworn 1857 comparison, so condition and exact attribution must remain part of the valuation.
