Rare 1863 Quarter Errors (List & Pictures)
An ordinary 1863 quarter graded MS64 sold for $3,172 in July 2026, without an FS-301 attribution. Among 1863 quarter errors, the listed repunched-date variety has an estimated whole-coin range of $150–$5,000.
This guide explains how to compare the date and why a valuable same-year coin is not automatically an example of the variety.
1863 Quarter Repunched Date FS-301 Error
The essential evidence is a repeatable group of extra raised date strokes. When a date punch entered a die more than once in slightly different positions, remnants of the earlier impression could remain beside the main digits.
Coins struck from that die reproduced those remnants. They did not need a second strike, and an extra-looking edge caused by damage does not establish the same process.
PCGS lists FS-301 for the Philadelphia circulation issue. The supplied record does not specify a direction or a particular digit remnant to substitute for a full reference match.
How to Identify
Begin with a clear date photograph of a quarter explicitly identified as FS-301. Keep the candidate upright at the same orientation and compare the positions of the extra strokes digit by digit.
A genuine remnant should remain a fixed raised part of the design as the light changes. Inspect any suspected line for a recessed scratch beside it, since damage can leave a raised lip that looks convincing from one direction.
Match the shape as well as the position of each surviving feature. One thick number or a seller’s variety label cannot establish the pattern by itself.
If wear obscures the needed details, keep the attribution unresolved until a specialist can examine it. Enlarging a blurred image cannot recover features that are no longer visible.
What It’s Worth
An identified FS-301 quarter has an estimated whole-coin range of $150–$5,000. That broad range includes the underlying coin’s value, with substantial differences for wear, preservation, and clear variety detail.
A PCGS MS64 1863 quarter sold for $3,172 on July 18, 2026. Its listing does not identify FS-301, so it is a condition comparison rather than a recorded sale of this repunched-date variety.
Cleaning, scratches, and weak surviving strokes can reduce the usefulness of that comparison. A high price or high grade alone does not prove an extra-date attribution.
Conclusion
For an 1863 quarter, confirm the date pattern before using the FS-301 name. The repeated raised strokes must agree with an identified example, and their visibility should be considered alongside the rest of the coin’s condition.
The $3,172 ordinary-coin result shows why whole-coin value and a variety premium are different questions. Preserve the date surface and use clear reference photographs rather than treating every extra-looking line as a repunched digit.
