Rare 1843 Dollar Errors (List & Pictures)
The final 4 is the place to start when checking 1843 dollar errors. A surviving earlier punch outline can identify a repunched date, with estimated whole-coin values of $400–$15,000.
An OC-1 dollar graded PCGS MS64 sold for $13,200 in August 2025. That result reflects an attractive unworn silver dollar as well as its small date feature, so compare the complete coin before using it as a price guide.
1843 Dollar An Extra Stroke beside the 4: Repunched Date Error
The date still reads 1843, but part of the 4 can show an earlier outline. The date punch entered the die more than once, leaving a trace of its earlier position.
That trace was then copied onto the coin during striking. It is not a different year stamped over a finished dollar or evidence that the coin itself received two blows.
PCGS lists the repunched 4 with OC-1, OC-2, and OC-3. These names identify pairings of front and back dies, rather than three separate date errors to add to one coin.
How to Identify
Keep the full date visible while studying the last digit with a magnifier. A crop containing only one tiny edge can hide the surrounding shapes needed for a reliable comparison.
Follow the 4’s main strokes and short end projections. Look for an extra outline that agrees with a recognized photograph rather than an isolated bright line.
Compare the same OC pairing before assigning its name. Do not borrow the clearest small detail from a different pairing and assume the rest of the coin must match.
Move the light across the suspected stroke to see whether it remains part of the raised design. Reflections shift with the lamp, while a scratch or later engraving cuts into the surface.
The repeated feature should also fit the surrounding wear. A sharply carved line through worn digits calls for a different explanation from an original punch trace that wore with the coin.
What It’s Worth
$400–$15,000 is the estimated range across worn and attractive unworn dollars with a matching repeated 4. Rarity, cleaning, marks, and overall preservation explain much of that spread.
PCGS records the OC-1 MS64 sale at $13,200 in August 2025. MS64 describes an unworn coin with relatively few marks.
A visible punch trace on a heavily worn dollar does not give it MS64 value. Likewise, the OC-1 result is not a fixed price for OC-2 or OC-3.
The figure is the price of the complete coin. Treating all of it as a premium for the extra stroke would overlook the value of the underlying early silver dollar.
Conclusion
For this date, a careful look at one digit is more useful than searching for a dramatic missing piece. Match the full 4 and the appropriate die pairing while checking for scratches or later alteration.
The $13,200 record shows what a well-preserved identified example achieved. A useful estimate for your coin must also reflect its wear, surfaces, and overall quality.
