Rare 1865 Dollar Errors (List & Pictures)
An extra outline on one letter and a second strike on an entire coin require different evidence. This 1865 dollar errors guide separates those cases, with estimated whole-coin values of $1,000–$40,000.
An ordinary-strike dollar with a widely repeated U sold for $25,850 in June 2014. Proofs have their own doubled-design variety, so establish the finish before choosing a matching photograph or price.
1865 Dollar A Repeated U or Matching Proof Details: Doubled-Design Group Error
The ordinary variety has a wide second outline at U in UNITED. Heritage noted no matching repetition elsewhere and suggested that the letter had been repunched into the die.
A variety catalog instead uses a doubled-die name. The visible repeated U is the shared observation, even though its cause has been interpreted differently.
The separate OC-P2 proof has doubled details on both faces. Those specially prepared collector coins need their own pattern comparison rather than the ordinary dollar’s isolated U.
How to Identify
For an ordinary dollar, follow the U’s wide extra contour and compare the neighboring letters. Repetition confined to one letter differs from a pattern spread across several design features.
For OC-P2, compare both faces with an identified proof. Bright surfaces alone cannot establish that the coin was made as a proof.
Move the light over the raised shapes to rule out reflections. A flat shelf from movement during striking also needs a different explanation from either documented variety.
What It’s Worth
$1,000–$30,000 covers identified ordinary examples, while matching proofs have a separate estimate of $1,500–$20,000 in usual collector grades. The prices apply to complete dollars.
The PCGS MS64 ordinary coin with the repeated U brought $25,850 in June 2014. Its unworn preservation contributes heavily to that result.
The amount is neither an OC-P2 proof sale nor a measured premium for the U alone. Worn or cleaned examples need a condition-appropriate comparison.
1865 Dollar Closely Overlapping Impressions: In-Collar Double Strike Error
A reported 1865 dollar received two close impressions while remaining inside the collar, the ring controlling its edge. The reverse preserves more obvious repetition than the front.
Collector Bert Schlosser described the coin in 2009 after ANACS identified the reverse double strike. Slight repeated front-border teeth support a coin-wide event rather than an extra shape confined to one die letter.
How to Identify
Trace several repeated reverse features and see whether one small shift explains their positions. A double strike need not leave a widely separated second portrait.
Then inspect the small front-border teeth mentioned in the collector’s account. The second blow can flatten earlier detail, so the two faces need not show equal repetition.
A shelf beside only one letter does not establish two strikes. Several consistent outlines and supporting detail on the other face give a stronger basis for identification.
What It’s Worth
$5,000–$40,000 is the estimate for an authenticated 1865 in-collar double strike. Preservation and the clarity of the two impressions guide the comparison.
A 1921 Morgan in-collar double strike graded ANACS MS64 sold for $8,050 in July 2002. That is a mechanism comparison from another design and year, not a sale of Schlosser’s dollar.
Conclusion
The ordinary repeated U, the OC-P2 proof pattern, and the close double strike each have a different identification route. Keep the finish and the extent of repetition clear before assigning a name.
The $25,850 result values one attractive ordinary dollar, while the $8,050 comparison belongs to a 1921 Morgan. Neither should replace the specific evidence on an 1865 candidate.
